topleft
topright
Pas d'expulsion de logement sans contrôle juridictionnel – le droit au logement et la Cour européenne des droits de l'Homme (Mc Cann c. Royaume-Uni - 13 mai 2008) Imprimer E-mail
Jeudi, 22 Janvier 2009 00:00

Nicolas BERNARD, Professeur aux Facultés universitaires Saint-Louis

Le droit au logement, on le sait, ne figure nullement au rang des prérogatives juridiques consacrées par la Convention européenne des droits de l'homme. Il n'empêche, la Cour européenne s'est emparée de cette problématique par le truchement notamment du droit au respect de la vie privée et familiale et du domicile (art. 8 de la Convention).

Il en va ainsi de l'arrĂŞt commentĂ©, qui a vu la haute cour condamner — Ă  l'unanimitĂ© — un État (le Royaume-Uni) dont la lĂ©gislation permet la rĂ©siliation extrajudiciaire d'un bail social. Mettre un terme Ă  un contrat de location sans contrĂ´le juridictionnel prĂ©alable s'assimile ainsi Ă  une atteinte "non nĂ©cessaire" (et "non proportionnĂ©e") aux droits reconnus par l'article 8.

Un an à peine auparavant, et à l'unanimité toujours, la Cour avait déjà, dans son arrêt Stanková c. Slovaquie du 9 octobre 2007, souligné la nécessité d'assortir l'éventuelle décision d'expulsion d'une solution de relogement. Et, dans l'arrêt Immobiliare Saffi c. L'Italie du 28 juillet 1999, les expulsions étaient déjà analysées comme des sources d' "importantes tensions sociales" susceptibles de mettre "en danger l'ordre public" (sans que cette qualification eût, ici, débouché sur une condamnation).

On le voit, une jurisprudence s'ébauche, dont il convient ici de rendre l'exacte mesure. Cet arrière-plan, qu'on brossera en premier lieu, est essentiel si l'on veut saisir la juste portée de l'arrêt McCann, qu'on analysera dans un second temps dès lors.

 

Fichiers joints:
Télécharger ce fichier (Mc Cann c. RU _ N. Bernard.pdf)Mc Cann c. RU _ N. Bernard.pdf266 Kb

Commentaires

avatar Torn
0
 
 
Now that?s sbutle! Great to hear from you.
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar taiqhfchkqk
0
 
 
YV0kaB ksumjpjgobqi
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar ihwzbxoq
0
 
 
kEBLSL , [url=http://ujzufzefzzxv.com/]ujzufzefzzxv[/url], [link=http://nhbgxpksjkod.com/]nhbgxpksjkod[/link], http://qudwwplxifjy.com/
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Stone
0
 
 
That's not just the best aneswr. It's the bestest answer!
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar kkfungkk
0
 
 
http://www.car-insur-onlin e.com/ cheapest auto insurance %-] http://www.insurerspolicie s.com/ health insurance jxowx http://www.homeinsuronline.com/ home insurance 198247
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Yippeee
0
 
 
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar ulikleafar
0
 
 
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Naturality
0
 
 
http://www.insur-online.net/ cheap health insurance %-[ http://www.carinsurersonli ne.net/ car insurance 8((( http://www.insurpartners.net/ home insurance 577698
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar th3n3wc4d
0
 
 
http://www.carinsuronline.com/ affordable auto insurance xuql http://www.soulpaintersblo g.com/cheaphealthinsu rance.html cheap health insurance =-[[[ http://www.insursmarket.com/ permanent life insurance otpybe
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar RonMurillo
0
 
 
http://www.medbalance.net/ priligy best buy :-(( http://www.ultraprix.net/ tramadol 8-] http://www.medicahelp.net/ seroquel %-DD
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar K4kTuZ
0
 
 
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Partishaa
0
 
 
http://www.insur-policies.com/ variable life insurance 423199 http://www.insurpartners.com/ company life insurance jfdce http://www.shannondawnphot ography.com/life_insurance.html life insurance 453952
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar samlmcr
0
 
 
http://www.viamedics.net/ buy zovirax online rx pharmaceutical >:-D http://www.onlinemedico.com/ cymbalta =-PP http://www.equimeds.net/ buying accutane 3570
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar cosmickitty
0
 
 
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar zeropdd
0
 
 
http://www.autoinsurerslis t.com/ Check Insurance Rates ttjgt http://www.getinsuronline.com/ Auto Insurance 123
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar irmodawg
0
 
 
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar jjaydelr
0
 
 
http://www.buytramadolhcl.net/ buy namebrand tramadol :-]] http://www.insuroffers.net/ auto insurance =]
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Arelenedhel
0
 
 
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar darkzeroxx
0
 
 
http://www.myinsuronline.com/ health insurance plans 418575 http://www.getinsuronline.net/ health insurance 23875
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar malamutemike
0
 
 
http://www.autoinsurerslis t.com/ State Farm Insurance - Brad Cutler gnndtx http://www.insurproviders.net/ car insurance 424
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar itstime4lunch
0
 
 
http://www.online-doxycycl ine.com/ how to take doxycycline coox http://www.good-bye-acne.com/ order accutane online rbf
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Paradisiaque
0
 
 
http://www.getyourinsur.com/ car insurance cxxcr http://www.insurproviders.net/ cheap california auto insurance 8)))
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar dogwomble
0
 
 
http://www.pillservice.net/ tramadol online 496 http://www.getremedy.net/ ultram anxiety 272
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar insomniacl
0
 
 
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar rsalcika
0
 
 
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar kevvingtons
0
 
 
http://www.insurplansonlin e.com/ State Farm Insurance 1472 http://www.insurerspolicie s.net/ home insurance =]]
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar TalGvili
0
 
 
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar namlnubq
0
 
 
ibghgwxf
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar viagra
0
 
 
ffrmiweb http://pgmpuc.com/ rqwldtmz [url=http://xdaajb.com/]rqwldtmz[/url]
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar nzequhlr
0
 
 
mzrddynu
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar viagra
0
 
 
zgxnswar http://dcuugg.com/ iyzemy [url=http://qirsaz.com/]iyzemy[/url]
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar payday loans
0
 
 
imlbei http://askpaydayloanss.net/ payday loans >:-OOO http://paydayloanslowr ates.net/ payday loan SHRAbE
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Emanuel
0
 
 
Oh yes, much better! I like! Now it is little bit too simple, but with little tweaks it can be even sdijex better. Good work http://roaringforkvehi cles.com/ Cialis online.
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar cialis
0
 
 
dshyuc http://edtoppills.com/ cialis oPbDlu http://edrxshipping.com/ buy viagra qoGtk
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Pharmb782
0
 
 
Hello! kgkaadd interesting kgkaadd site! I'm really like it! Very, very kgkaadd good!
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Pharme227
0
 
 
Very nice site! cheap viagra
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Pharmg92
0
 
 
Very nice site! [url=http://aieopxy.com/osoarxv/2.html]cheap cialis[/url]
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Pharmf56
0
 
 
Very nice site! [url=http://aieopxy.com/osoarxv/98/a1a.html]cheap cialis[/url] , [url=http://aieopxy.com/osoarxv/98/a2a.html]cheap cialis[/url] , [url=http://aieopxy.com/osoarxv/98/a3a.html]cheap cialis[/url] , [url=http://aieopxy.com/osoarxv/98/a4a.html]cheap cialis[/url] , [url=http://aieopxy.com/osoarxv/98/a5a.html]cheap cialis[/url] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar valium
0
 
 
Hello!
[URL=http://piscataquisdemo crats.com/]cheap valium[/URL] , [URL=http://www.hhpcboard.org/]valium online[/URL] , [URL=http://www.gwbush04.com/]adipex[/URL] , [URL=http://dawg-pound.net/]cheap vimax[/URL] , [URL=http://www.fairydah.com/]valium online[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar cialis
0
 
 
Hello!
[URL=http://bumcialis.com/]cialis[/URL] , [URL=http://cialispadla.com/]cialis[/URL] , [URL=http://bumcialis.com/][/URL] , [URL=http://viagraonlinechp.com/]viagra[/URL] , [URL=http://cialisonlinechp.com/]cialis[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar phentermine
0
 
 
Aloha!
[URL=http://phentermine37blog.com]phentermine[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar red_cialis_viagra
0
 
 
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar adipex
0
 
 
Aloha!
[URL=http://adipex24x7.net]adipex phentermine[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar adipex
0
 
 
Hi there!
[URL=http://adipexstart.com]adipex[/URL] , [URL=http://adipex-p.webs.com]buy adipex[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar provigil
0
 
 
Aloha!
[URL=http://modafinil-provi gil.com]cheap provigil[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar instant cash advance
0
 
 
grhipzt [url=http://instantcashadva nce4u.com/]instant cash advance[/url] >:]] [url=http://instantcashadva nce4u.co.uk/]cash advance[/url] HdzBMp [url=http://paydayloans24us.com/]payday loans[/url] 1482
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar viagra
0
 
 
Hello!
[URL=http://bcheap-viagra.com/]viagra[/URL] , [URL=http://bcheap-cialis.com/]cialis[/URL] , [URL=http://accutane-skin.com/]accutane[/URL] , [URL=http://her-propecia.com/]propecia pills[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar viagra
0
 
 
Hi there!
[URL=http://vzikviagra.com/]viagra[/URL] , [URL=http://scheapcialis.com]cheap cialis[/URL] , [URL=http://scheapviagra.com/]cheap viagra[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar viagra
0
 
 
uwgmcp [url=http://qviagra.it/]viagra[/url] FNovWF [url=http://qcialis.fr/]cialis[/url] bOetzO [url=http://qcialis.eu/]cialis kaufen[/url] 6041 [url=http://qcialis.it/]cialis[/url] >:-OOO [url=http://qviagra.eu/]viagra kaufen[/url] =-] [url=http://qviagra.fr/]acheter viagra[/url] :-O
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Koop cialis
0
 
 
zeqwwwgi [url=http://goedkope-apothe ek.eu/]Koop cialis[/url] >:]] [url=http://billige-tablett en.eu/]cialis billig[/url] >:-OOO [url=http://farmacia-barato.eu/generic-norplan t.html]norplant[/url] >:]] [url=http://billiga-apotek.eu/]viagra[/url] :-O [url=http://pharmacyjp.net/]????ĂŻ?????[/url] wqtjh [url=http://edrxtabs.com/]viagra[/url] fdgKSr
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar ambien
0
 
 
Aloha!
[URL=http://howsleepwell.com]ambien[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar zolpidem
0
 
 
Perfect!
[URL=http://swambien.com]zolpidem[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar payday loans
0
 
 
xhriabap [url=http://usapaydayloans24.com/]payday loans[/url] ceUAS [url=http://fastpaydayloans cash.net/]instant cash advance[/url] kosxEK [url=http://paydayloansexpr ess4u.com/]cash advance[/url] >:-OOO [url=http://paydayloansonli ne4u.co.uk/]payday loans[/url] 5041
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar klonopin
0
 
 
Hi there!
[URL=http://klonopin-online.webs.com/]cheap klonopin[/URL] , [URL=http://ativan-online.webs.com/]ativan[/URL] , [URL=http://ambien-here.webs.com/]ambien[/URL] , [URL=http://valium-gb.webs.com/]cheap valium[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar payday loans
0
 
 
nfxlyhdp [url=http://uspaydayloans24.com/]payday loans[/url] GYNsbh [url=http://servicepaydaylo ans.co.uk/]payday loans[/url] %-[[[ [url=http://servicepaydaylo ans.com/]payday loan Canada[/url] >:]]
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar provigil
0
 
 
Aloha!
[URL=http://modafinil-g.webs.com/]buy provigil[/URL] , [URL=http://zolpidem-g.webs.com/]zolpidem[/URL] , [URL=http://phentermine-375mg.webs.com/]cheap phentermine 37 5mg[/URL] , [URL=http://xanax-g.webs.com/]buy xanax[/URL] , [URL=http://tramadol-u.webs.com/]tramadol[/URL] ,
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Pustishka123
0
 
 
Thinking about that, where to buy Atarax (http://atarax25mg.com/), buy Generic Levitra (http://www.levitradosage.net/), Buy Cymbalta (http://cymbalta60mg.com/), buy zyrtec (http://zyrtecdosage.org/), buy Levitra 20mg (http://buylevitra20mg.org/), Buy Kamagra (http://buykamagraoralj elly.net/) or buy kamagra ora ljelly (http://buykamagraoralj elly.net/), buy Sildenafil citrate (http://sildenafilcitra te100mg.com/), buy tadacip (http://tadacipla.com/), buy Duphasto (http://buyduphaston.org/), buy Kamagra Oral Jelly (http://buykamagraoralj elly.net/), or you know, we have the best and the fastest service. The best way to purchase atarax (http://buyatarax.biz/) it buy atarax online (http://buyatarax.biz/)! In addition, you can order Atarax 25mg (http://atarax25mg.com/), Cymbalta 60mg (http://cymbalta60mg.com/), doxycycline hyclate (http://doxycyclinehycl ate.biz/) or doxycycline hyclate 100mg (http://doxycyclinehycl ate.biz/), tadacip (http://tadacipla.com/) or tadacip 20 mg(http://tadacipla.com/), zyrtec 10mg (http://zyrtecdosage.org/) or other suitable for you zyrtec dosage (http://zyrtecdosage.org/), Levitra 20mg (http://buylevitra20mg.org/), Amitriptyline 10mg (http://amitriptyline10mg.net/), convenient Levitra dosage (http://www.levitradosage.net/), Kamagra Oral Jelly (http://buykamagraoralj elly.net/), Sildenafil citrate 100mg (http://sildenafilcitra te100mg.com/), Duphaston 10mg (http://buyduphaston.org/), Kamagra Oral Jelly (http://buykamagraoralj elly.net/) directly at the house. Buy Cymbalta online (http://cymbalta60mg.com/) or buy doxycycline online (http://doxycyclinehycl ate.biz/)! If you can't decide viagra vs cialis vs Levitra (http://viagravscialisv slevitra.com/), viagra vs cialis (http://viagravscialisv slevitra.com/) and also cialis vs levitra (http://viagravscialisv slevitra.com/) then here you will find the answer! Also very convenient and practical to buy tadacip online (http://tadacipla.com/)! Any medical products may be delivered to the house. Don't miss your chance!
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Pustishka123
0
 
 
Don't pass by the favorable offer!! You can buy tadalafil (http://generictadalafi l.org/) in our online drugstore. We not only offer excellent prices, but also favorable conditions of purchase.
We offer you to buy suhagra (http://suhagrapro.com) - the next working out of company Cipla, the famous Indian pharmaceutical manufacture. Evaluate the pros suhagra 100mg (http://suhagrapro.com) or suhagra 100 (http://suhagrapro.com) you can right now. Make a reservation suhagra online (http://suhagrapro.com) in our pharmacy, and in the shortest possible time Suhagra (http://suhagrapro.com) will be delivered to any address.
We Present to Your attention the drug viagra sildenafil (http://viagrasildenafi l100mg.com/). viagra sildenafil 100mg (http://viagrasildenafi l100mg.com/) has been the subject of a thorough and long-term research. High activity sildenafil 100mg (http://viagrasildenafi l100mg.com/) at treatment of sexual problems is checked up by millions men worldwide.
Generic tadalafil (http://generictadalafi l.org/) has perfectly proved in the market of sexual stimulators and it is applied by many men, suffering from problems with erection.
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
avatar Pustishka123
0
 
 
Hello! We offer highly efficient sildenafil citrate (http://buysildenafilci trate100mg.com/) at affordable prices. Our pharmacy online offers buy sildenafil citrate (http://buysildenafilci trate100mg.com/) - the best medicine to improve erection, at the best prices on the internet. In the case, if you need buy sildenafil citrate 100mg (http://buysildenafilci trate100mg.com/), but you do not want to overpay - our drugstore can help you. At our pharmacy buy sildenafil (http://buysildenafilci trate100mg.com/) in the popular dosage sildenafil citrate 100mg (http://buysildenafilci trate100mg.com/)is easy.
In addition, you can select and order the best and popular medications for potency, one of which is Tadalafil 20mg (http://tadalafil20mg.org/)
Besides, we offer to buy cheap levitra online (http://buycheaplevitra online.net/) at a very affordable price. Due to the absolute safety cheap Levitra (http://buycheaplevitra online.net/), it effectiveness and speed of action on the organism, cheap levitra online (http://buycheaplevitra online.net/) has gained its popularity and demand is high. Buy cheap Levitra (http://buycheaplevitra online.net/) and you will not regret, purchase levitra online (http://buycheaplevitra online.net/) in only in our drugstore.
Only now we have the perfect offer for you buy cheap levitra online (http://cheaplevitrapri ce.com/). Cheap Levitra (http://cheaplevitrapri ce.com/) is an efficient medicinal agent for the treatment of erectile dysfunction. Buy cheap Levitra (http://cheaplevitrapri ce.com/) right now at the most profitable levitra price (http://cheaplevitrapri ce.com/).
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire
Annuler
Nom *
Code   
Soumettre ce commentaire